"Flinstoneyerfired" <mmurph@onlink.net> wrote in message
news:8139fee4-838a-4405-bc60-c559af54f895@y38g2000hsy.googlegroups.com...
[snip]
>
> It can work that way- another way it can work is that you were brought
> up in a culture that considers playing cricket a viable sport. In this
> way, you may have played cricket in school and were thought of as a
> good player- hence, you still play it. It may not work quite like that
> if you were brought up in a culture that considers hockey or football
> a viable sport.
>
> The same can be said for music- maybe you hung with buddies who spun
> some Zappa LPs and got stoned to them. You are far more likely to have
> liked Zappa at that time, because your peers did. You may either still
> spin them and feel some nostalgia, appreciate the music as the work of
> a genius, think that "the drugs did it", that the music was crap that
> stoners listened to, think that it's passe, or any other outcome you
> can possibly think of.
>
> However, if you listen to Zappa's work critically, what you think of
> his stuff is totally up to you. You may think it's utter crap, you may
> think it's genius, you may think it's humourous or stupid, etc. In a
> case like Zappa's music (as with any other music, perhaps) it helps to
> do some reading so you can get a kind of glimpse as to where he may
> have been coming from.
>
> I think Zappa will loom large as an important musical figure as
> history begins (has begun already!) to write the book on Zappa. He
> embodies the cynicism and rejection of a generation who grew up to
> become disillusioned with the idealism present in the sixties. The
> obtuse way that he expressed his frustration with mainstream society
> in his music alienated and confused a lot of people.
>
> That we are talking about his music in a passionate way tends to lend
> credibility to his work- if the music wasn't substantial, there would
> be nothing to discuss.
>
>
I was "turned onto" Zappa (even though I'd known the name for years and
years) by a friend. He was very disappointed when I told him it was crap.
The whole time that I was thinking how dreadful it all was, I recognised
that there was some genius in there. No matter how clever it was, however,
I didn't find much that was palatable or to be in any way entertaining.
My friend and I actually have very similar tastes in many ways, but this
wasn't one of them.
As has been pointed out in previous posts in this and other threads, beauty
is in the eye of the beholder. The beholder, even as an individual, isn't
necessarily a constant either. Tastes and opinions can change with the
mood.
My opinion of Frank is unlikely to change in the near future, however.
--
George
"Dolphins, Eskimos, who cares?! It's all a bunch of tree hugging hippie
crap!" - Eric Cartman - 20 August 1997